Skip to main content

Kneedful Things

The first and second rules of Fight Club ought to be applied to having knee replacement surgery:

“You DO NOT talk about knee replacement surgery. With anybody.”

Failure to follow the rules will result in confusion.

Dangerous, tremendous confusion.

That is especially true if you are an American expat living in Taiwan with contacts in both nations who have undergone the surgical procedure and are eager to talk about it. Add to that the ubiquity of YouTube videos from therapists and patients alike, and you have a child’s recipe for muddle pies.

You see …

The adventure that is a full knee replacement begins many years before the surgery itself. It starts with the grudging admission that a knee, or both knees, have completely lost their youthful vigor. I’m talking about that time when walking a mere 4,000 steps — what was once a friendly half-hour stroll — becomes a two-hour trudge through discomfort. The feet get blamed, and they step forward to point a finger — er, a toe — at the shoes. The shoes blame the socks, and they in turn are unraveled by the indignities of impugnment.

When foot massages, custom-made shoes, and high-quality socks fail to up the pace, everybody blames the “bad” back. A local hospital bone doctor looks at the X-rays and pounces upon the favored “lose weight” mantra. Om. My. God.

Then comes the day when one of those expensive full-body checkups gives you the suggestion that your knees, both of them, are truly fucked. A doctor you trust in a hospital you trust passes you along to an orthopedic surgeon who turns out to be greatly admired by patients and medical professionals alike. He orders another set of X-rays and confirms: Yes, your knees are sincerely fucked, forever and ever, Amen. Then he pulls out his New Year’s Eve Party regalia and exclaims: “Out with the old, in with the new!”

As the world’s most well-feathered chicken, you say thanks and refuse to commit. You’ve already been forced into operating rooms by run-ins with cancers, and none of these surgery experiences has been at all pleasant.

So, you stumble and sometimes tumble face-first into another year. You walk. Slowly. You even go to Tokyo, twice, managing some 14,000 steps daily upon blistered, bloodied feet. And so it goes.

Then you start talking to others.

You tell another doctor you’re considering knee replacement surgery. “That’s great!” he says. “My mother-in-law had it done three times!” He sees the look of confusion on your face and rushes to explain: “She’s very active.”

You tell your expat friend who’s had two surgeries.

You tell your best friend in Taiwan whose mother in the island’s rice-growing region knows plenty of old women who replaced their knees through surgeries.

You tell your brother “back home” who over the course of three months has undergone two knee replacement surgeries.

You tell those Facebook friends you trust the most, and they speak of their own family members who stood taller after knee replacement surgeries.

Everybody says: Do it!

Rule One and Two. Remember?

Silence is Golden?

The consensus on knee replacement surgery is that the procedure can only end well.

(The only exception being a British neighbor in Taipei who developed a post-surgical bone infection that his doctor said was incurable — “Bad Luck, Mate — but which he claims to have self-cured through a four-hour daily regimen of walking his dog outdoors.  …A year later he would be gone, a victim of pancreatic cancer. The dog lives on. What a fucking travesty of misfortune.)  

Rule One and Two kick in when you get to the recovery stage. That’s exactly when you should talk to nobody but your surgeon and the hospital’s physical therapist.

You see, post-operative recovery and therapy experiences seem to differ for everyone. Asking others about their post-surgical recoveries and therapeutic methods will only sow confusion into your mind during the weeks that follow the removal of your stitches. That’s especially true if your contacts are from different backgrounds, ages, and nations. You’re not really going to know what to expect. It’s better that you expect the unknowing.

The confusion will be … unhelpful.

For me the confusion actually kicked in a month or so before surgery. My brother in the United States had both knees replaced, and he couldn’t stop singing the praises of a mechanical device that wrapped around his knee and delivered a steady flow of cooling ice water. You see, ice packing is still the most effective aid for reducing post-surgical inflammation, the inevitable but unhelpful swelling that hampers healing and recovery.

The device is quite affordable when purchased in the United States, but the price pretty much triples on the local Taiwan market. Naturally, I tried to buy it from the United States. What I didn’t know is that this simple therapeutic machine is listed as a “medical device” in Taiwan, and can only be imported if you have a valid certificate to do so from the Ministry of Health. Having one shipment turned away and trapped in Customs with no explanation why, I naturally tried a second time. On that second go-around, however, I used a better shipping company, and they explained the snafu. I was able to give them authority to deal with Customs and have the package returned to the United States, enabling me to get a refund on the product (but not the shipping charges). God Bless Transparency. Lesson learned: don’t use the “free shipping” option and swallow the extra expense of hiring the shipping agent yourself. You won’t regret it.

In the end, using old-fashioned ice packs was good enough for my recovery. But the cold water machine would have been really cool. Pun intended.

Continuing on in the spirit of wickedness, let me share my own experience of recovery and therapy after having a full-knee replacement using a combination of metal and plastic inserts.

The recovery actually began three months before the surgery, when the hospital phoned to confirm the surgery date had been set for mid-October, as per my request. I had hoped for seasonal weather that would be cooler and less-conducive to a sweaty leg, a soppy bandage, and the discomfort of swinging between a room that is either too hot or too cold. In this choice, I was right.

The three-month head start also allowed me to strengthen my leg through a series of simple, but sometimes challenging, exercises recommended by a therapist at the hospital. Another doctor at the hospital also met me, and suggested I “lose at least 3 kg” and ride the stationary exercise bike about 20 minutes per day. I ended up doing about 40 minutes each day, and losing about 6 kg through the combination of exercise (daily walking plus the bike) and drastically cutting back on white rice consumption.

The Experience

My surgery took place in the early morning. Waking through the amnesia afterward was difficult. Somehow I heard the recovery room nurse trying to rouse me from my sleep, but it felt like a dream and I fought against waking. I recall thinking, “I don’t want to wake up.” That was weird.

Having a nurse’s aid in the hospital from surgery to release was required, and the woman chosen to care for me demonstrated a “strong” character. Strong as in forceful, easily infuriated, and short on patience. She was perfect for an indecisive wuss like me. 

There is always a degree of indignity associated with helplessness, and under doctor’s orders I was not allowed to leave the bed in the remainder of the day following the operation. Unlike previous surgeries, however, I was not as weak as a newborn kitten. Nor was I undone by pain, as an insert allowed the injection of a painkiller directly into the knee twice a day in addition to the painkiller dosed into me through the IV line in my arm.

In my journal I wrote of that post-op afternoon: “The doctor came and showed me the ‘before’ and ‘after’ X rays of my knee, and only through the comparison did I finally understand just how amazing it was that I could walk as much as I did over the previous year.”

Over the course of that afternoon separate nurses and a doctor came in, each with advice on how to recover more swiftly. Unfortunately, some confusion existed, and that threatened my working relationship with my private nurse’s aide.

You see, the hospital had given me a massage device to encourage blood flow in the leg. This device is potentially life-saving, as I’ll explain later.

The problem arose when someone suggested I wear this mechanical device overnight.

This therapeutic medical device seemed to be some sort of perverse combination between a Scottish bagpipe and an Alien facehugger. It wrapped around my leg and hissed air into successive bags with enough compression to push the blood flow through the entire limb, working in stages as if three different blood pressure devices had been set off one after the other.

On top of this I told my nurse’s aide to wrap the blue ice packs that are important for the reduction of swelling. The private aide said these two items together, overnight, would be a bad idea.

She was right.

What I didn’t know is that every nurse’s aide is required to quit the patient if they are unable to achieve a good overnight sleep for two consecutive days. My aide got very little sleep that first night, and it was entirely my fault.

My eventual discomfort in having both the squeezing massage device and the heavy ice packs wrapped around my leg led to me waking her up so she could help me unwrap all that stuff from me. At 3am I woke her again because, well, I’d had a bit of an accident when using the plastic urinal jar. My cup overfloweth, if you know what I mean.

Indignity.

My aide achieved a special degree of grumpiness the next day, and reveled in saying, “I told you so.” Nothing infuriates me quite as much as, “I told you so.” She managed to say it many times.

This wasn’t going to be a good day.

My surgeon visited again in the morning, and found me seated, enjoying my breakfast. He told me I could aim for a total of two hours, broken up into manageable segments throughout the day. Sitting up is actually good for the digestive tract, he said.

He also said I should begin using the knee-bending machine, the “CPM” or “Continuous Passive Motion” device. This device could also be rented for home use after discharge from the hospital, but medical research suggested that it was relatively unhelpful in achieving the degree of motion or flexibility recommended by doctors. To get a full range of movement in my leg, I would have to rely upon old-fashioned “hands on” physical therapy. 

For the days of hospitalization, however, the CPM was perfect in loosening the knee. It could flex the leg to at least 110 degrees, and did so very slowly. The aide said that on the first day, most patients could handle 90 degrees. Anyway, it wasn’t a terrible experience and I had to do it four times each day, with ice packing for a half hour before and after each session.

My notes in the journal that morning: “Exhausted and lonely.” I was feeling sorry for myself, even though physically everything was going well. And then, that first afternoon after surgery, the painkiller being fed into my arm was stopped. A slight tug of discomfort settled in. The doctor later confirmed that the second day after surgery would likely be the most uncomfortable for me. Who ever imagined I’d miss the IV drip?

That morning, and again in the afternoon, my aide took me for a stroll in the hallway. I wanted to do more, but she wisely held me back. I was too ambitious, a common error among patients. While we were strolling a physical therapist came along, and she led me back into the room to teach me the exercises I should perform four times every day. Here again I was glad I had delayed the surgery for so long, as the exercises she asked me to perform were the same I’d been practicing daily over the previous three months to strengthen my muscles (while also losing weight).

That evening, I obeyed my nurse’s aide and slept without the squeegee device or the ice packs wrapped around my knee. She in turn allowed me to keep two urinal jars next to the bed, and I promised to stop sipping water after 9pm. Our compact worked, and she got a good night’s sleep. 

On the second day after the operation, my surgeon came and found me walking. I asked him why everyone was worried about deep vein thrombosis (DVT), and he said that coagulant drugs had been administered during the surgery to make the operation less messy. On top of that, the wound was very close to a major artery. This explained the massage device and the DVT Compression socks on each leg, as well as the knee-bend exercises I should be doing throughout the day.

I learned something.

Three days after surgery the doctor said I could be discharged the next morning. The DVT sock was removed from my non-surgical leg.

The therapist arrived to show me how to climb stairs. If this had been a test, I would’ve aced it. You see, grabbing the banister and hauling myself up using only my “good” leg was my normal way of ascension and descension for a couple of years already. Yeah, my “bad” leg was really that bad.

From the hospital I went straight into a hotel.

Mistake.

My home is almost entirely stairs. When I’d had a major surgery a few years earlier, I was not allowed to climb stair for at least a week, so upon my discharge from the hospital I went to a decent hotel near my home. A friend arranged for me to have three meals delivered daily. The room had a comfortable sofa upon which I reclined while composing PowerPoint lectures that were forwarded to the professor who was substituting for me in the final weeks of the semester while I recovered.

Assuming that my heavenly staircase of a home would not be conducive to recovering from knee replacement surgery, I’d booked (non-refundable) a room in the same hotel for five days. Foolish move.

What I didn’t know was that the hotel was under new ownership, and the room I reserved had very little furniture — certainly no comfy chair. The new décor was uncomfortably sterile, almost industrial: a bed, a wicker chair, and a thin desklike structure built into the wall. No carpeting, which I guess was good for a guy who had to practice going back and forth with a four-legged walker. I was wrong in assuming that I would have trouble with stairs.

The hotel stay passed quickly enough, albeit somewhat uncomfortably. It was not always easy getting someone to bring me bags of ice, and the in-room refrigerator had no freezer compartment. Keeping my knee cool was too much of a challenge.

A good friend came by once or twice a day to help me do the recommended knee-stretching exercise that the doctor demanded. This was the only exercise that was not part of my previously taught routine.

Basically, my friend had to hoist my leg up and push the lower half — the calf — toward my thigh. The knee inflammation made this nearly impossible, and the pain was terrifying. The problem was that I was distinctly warned not to use my leg or knee muscles to either raise the leg or bend it at the knee. It all had to be external force.

Eventually I found a way to pull my thigh up using a towel, and weighing down the lower part of the leg with my other leg. I could judge how far to push into the agonizing pain until it felt like I would be doing damage if I went any further.

It was “therapy,” but I called it “torture.”

Two weeks after surgery I returned to the hospital for a checkup. The surgeon lay me down and grabbed my leg, hoisting my leg up and shoving the bent knee toward my face. Of course, I screamed. From my own “torture” sessions I’d thought I was doing quite well, but he thought I was nowhere near the goal he’d set for me.

“After surgery, when you were still under anesthesia, I bent your leg all the way. I know you can do it.” Then he said the adage I hate the most: “No pain, no gain!”

Back at home I discovered a new way to bend my knee without assistance from anybody. Grabbing my ankle with a long cloth that had no resistance in it, I pulled my lower leg toward my thigh, allowing the foot to slide along the mattress. Ten times for each session, four sessions per day. Still “torture,” but somehow I increased the ability to endure more stretching over longer periods of time. My friend would visit each evening, photograph the “bend,” and measure the angle. (He actually went so far as to consult an engineer about how to measure the angle of the bend.)

Final result: I could bend the knee about 146 degrees after almost two months, with only limited pain at the extreme bend.

The First and Second Rule!

Early on in this recollection I warned that talking to others about full knee replacement surgery would only encourage unhelpful confusion. Here’s what I mean:

1.) Unhelpful Expectations. When I told a friend about my upcoming surgery, he sent me a video of an elder woman in his village cycling away on a regular bicycle self-rigged into a stationary exercise bike. The accompanying test assured me she was just a week out of her own knee replacement surgery, and that other older women were tootling through the streets on their motor scooters within a week of having undergone the procedure.

And so I assumed that within a week of my surgery I’d be able to walk the 3,000 steps from my hotel room to the local cinema where I so desperately wanted to see a new Horror film that opened the same week that my knee was opened up to the surgeon’s expert hammer and saw. Once I was situated in the hotel, however, I realized the futility of my expectation. The reports from my friend had to be exaggerations or misunderstandings.

Cue the music for my heartbrokenness.

2.) Therapeutic Confusions. An acquaintance of mine had a serious cycling accident a couple of years ago, and our mutual friend failed to understand that his injury was far more serious than even the massive violence of the surgery I would be undertaking. My friend spoke of the brace that was worn by this acquaintance for many months, and on multiple occasions encouraged me to purchase one in advance.

I knew the brace would be unnecessary, but worse was the secret regret I felt. Many years earlier a fellow “foreigner” had given me his discarded brace after his own recovery from a heavy motorcycling accident. Like me, he had no idea what to do with the expensive leg brace and was leaving Taiwan for other shores. I held onto it for a few years, but left it behind when I cleared retired from my teaching job. I asked a colleague if she might be able to donate it to a charity organization, but I have no idea if that actually happened. All I know is that I was embarrassed for having given away such an expensive piece of medical hardware. Oh, guilt. Superfluous guilt, but there it is.

The challenge of buying unnecessary equipment occurred again when I spoke to my brother in the United States, hoping to learn from his experience. Aside from encouraging me toward the cooling pad, he also advised I purchase something to make using the toilet easier. He showed a device he had used in his home, something that looked like a reversed walker that offered bars on either side of the toilet to help the handicapped patient sit and stand. You might see them in the “handicapped” facilities in public spaces like department stores.

I looked locally for such a piece of hardware, and mistakenly purchased a rather expensive thing that turned out to be ill-adjusted for my home.  It was a stand-alone “throne” for patients who cannot ambulate to a bathroom. It now sits in storage. The day will come, no doubt, when someone I know — or, Gods forbid, I — will find this portable toilet invaluable.

Once my surgery was over and I had deposited myself in the hotel room, I videophoned my brother to bemoan my therapeutic torture. My brother was surprised by my doctor’s imposed goal of being able to squat like a youthful monk.

In the same conversation I discovered the huge gap in recovery therapy procedures. My brother was delivered by van to a therapy center at least three days a week, where he was led through an hour’s worth of motions that included an exercise bicycle. No tortured screaming at all though he did tell me it “hurt like hell.”

And then there was the observation of a fellow American expatriate who had her surgery in a different Taipei City hospital some years ago. She taxied her way to the therapy center, and was never told about pain and gain. “They approach it really differently at your hospital,” she said.

Making matters worse, I turned to YouTube. Googling “therapy exercises two weeks after knee replacement surgery,” I landed upon a bevvy of videos from “Hi, I’m a professional therapist” therapists. I noticed in these videos some of the “do it yourself” methods that my brother spoke of — approaches that he practiced under the practiced hands of professional recovery practitioners. (It took a lot of practice to write that impractical sentence.)

These videos and my brother’s suggestions eventually resulted in the method I used to bend my knee: the rope-around-the-ankle trick. Of course, the American therapists displayed a specially designed rubber device that cupped the patient’s foot, but my improvised long cloth worked just as well. Thankfully, it also relieved my good friend of the daily burden of hoisting my leg up in the air like Sisyphus and his punishment stone. Now I could scream in agony on my own.

What disturbed me most at the time was the pungent disquiet of not knowing if I was getting “enough” therapy or if the leg-flexing I was doing was damaging my new knee. Also, at the two-week mark I wondered if, as the YouTube videos suggested, I should be doing “more” activity like squats, bike riding, and stair stepping.

I was overcome with uncertainty, with confusion.

A phone call to the hospital case worker reassured me: “Don’t push too much too soon.” I was told just to keep walking in circles at home, continue doing my leg exercises (including crucial ankle bending) and flexions, and keeping the bandages clean. “When can I drive?” I asked. “Drive?” the case worker asked: “Where do you need to drive to?” End of that line of inquiry.

Most helpful was the good luck that my closest friend, who was visiting me in hospital after my surgery, made video of the instructions given to me by the therapist and doctor when they came to my room. If not for reviewing those videos that he shared with me, I would likely have forgotten how to do even the least of the knee-bending exercises. In looking at the videos now, I see that I was actually offered a few different routines, including pushing my ankle back while sitting in a tall chair.

Appreciated Encouragement

Writing this at the end of four months after surgery, I look back once again with a tremendous sense of appreciation for those words of encouragement from a couple of highly cherished friends overseas. One of these dear friends told me her elder brother had undergone surgery for both knees, and while the recovery was painful, months later he was extremely grateful for having done it. He stood taller and walked more easily just a couple of months after the second knee was done.

Another wonderful word of encouragement came from a physician in Britain who responded to my text from the hospital the night before my own operation. “Just remember,” she wrote, “this is not the first such surgery your doctor has performed.” My surgeon “knows what he’s doing,” she said. In truth, my doctor was clearly among the best in this field in Taiwan, and perhaps globally. My anxiety was natural, but ultimately unnecessary.

And besides, no pain no gain.

What did I have to lose?

 

____

Graphic:
James Ward (1769-1859)
“A Human Skeleton” (Open Access, Google Art Project)

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

"Invisible Nation" and the Indivisibility Difference

Invisible Nation will probably disappoint Taiwan audiences, largely because the documentary was produced for is intended for international audiences, though the film is pragmatically “for Taiwan.” Completed in 2023 and made available to the global documentary film circuit last year, Invisible Nation finally found its way to movie screens throughout Taiwan on June 13, 2025 — a Friday the 13 th release, to be precise.  Produced and directed by Vanessa Hope , Invisible Nation was filmed with the cooperation and encouragement of Taiwan’s first democratically elected female president, Tsai Ying-wen (whose Administration of the Republic of China spanned two terms, 2016-2024). Hope could easily be understood as something of a “China hand,” though she would probably not be comfortable with the label. Prior to becoming a filmmaker, Hope had been a scholar of international studies for the Council on Foreign Relations in her hometown of New York City. She also earned a doctorate from C...

Trauma, Silence, and "Woman Islands"

Here’s a selection of excerpts from the 2011 English translation (by C.J. Anderson-Wu) of Chung Wenyin’s 1998 novel, Woman Islands ( 女島紀行 ). I provide it here in the hope that it might entice students and scholars, especially those with an interest in Women’s Studies and Feminist Literature, to consider taking up this book as a subject for literary criticism. I have straightened up the grammatical style of the original translation that had attempted to portray the “untranslatable” style of the Chinese text and the author’s insistence upon “maintaining the awkwardness of her writing instead of smoothing it out for English readers.”  Although I can appreciate that desire, I chose instead to alter some of the sentence constructions that might come across as more a result of poor proofreading than of conscious choice by the translator. I’m going to hope this won’t be a problem, and I apologize in advance if anyone is offended by my editing choices. But then again, if you want to see...

Police Motto: Make Study, Not Protest

Oh my goodness, the mess on my desk is that bad! I'm referring to the foot-high pile of papers and assorted documents that has been sitting there, well, for over a year according to the date on a news clipping I just unearthed midway through the pile. I see why I saved the article. I was inte rested in a front-page Taipei Times (4 December 2008) piece titled "Losheng Activists Block Demolition." The article is about the last holdouts of protesters and residents of the Losheng Leprosy Sanatorium in Taipei County (Sinjhuang City). The sanatorium was partially demolished to make way for an MRT line extension, despite protests and also despite promises from Ma the Incompetent who as a candidate promised to preserve the Japanese colonial era landmark (and the only home ever known by many or most of the patients). The quote that caught my eye was: "Sinjhuang Precinct Chief Hsu Yung-sheng said through a loudspeaker (to the students barricaded inside and protesters outside)...